Choosing between All-Star and Rawlings is one of the most common decisions catchers face at every level of the game. Both brands have earned their place behind the plate — but they take different approaches to protection, fit, and performance.
All-Star is widely regarded as the gold standard for serious catchers. Known for their innovative designs and superior protection, All-Star gear is built for players who demand the best. Their mitts offer exceptional pocket depth and break-in, while their protective gear sets the bar for impact absorption and mobility.
Rawlings brings decades of baseball and softball heritage to every piece of gear. Their catcher's equipment is trusted at all levels for its reliable protection, classic styling, and consistent performance. Rawlings offers strong value across youth, high school, and collegiate levels.
Shop & Compare at Field General
At Field General, we carry a curated selection of All-Star and Rawlings catcher's gear so you can find the right fit for your game. Compare and contrast the catchers' gear from All-Star and Rawlings at Field General. We are your one-stop shop for both brands.
